Chapter 10: The Ultimate Betrayal
By Monday morning, the true scope of the disaster was mapped out, but so was my path to absolute victory. I had retained the most ruthless real estate and family law attorney in Louisville, a man named Arthur Vance (no relation to Marcus, ironically), who took one look at my file and practically salivated at the open-and-shut nature of the fraud.
"She’s thoroughly screwed," Arthur had chuckled, adjusting his spectacles as he reviewed Brenda the Notary’s sworn affidavit. "Not only will she serve time for the forgery, but we can civilly sue her for the forty thousand in credit card debt and the misappropriated funds. We’ll garnish whatever pension or wages she has for the rest of her natural life."
I felt a dark satisfaction, but it was hollow. I was still broke, my credit was ruined, and my wife was deeply traumatized.
That afternoon, I received a text from an unknown number.
Colin. It’s Aunt Martha. We posted Judith’s bail. She is staying at my house. She wants to meet. She says she has something that belongs to Evelyn, and she’ll only hand it over in person. Don't call the police. Just meet us at the diner on 4th street at 3 PM.
I showed the text to Evelyn. She turned pale. "What does she have of mine?"
"I don't know," I said, my jaw tightening. "But I am going to find out. And I am ending this today."
I drove to the diner with Arthur's advice ringing in my ears: Record everything. Do not lose your temper. Let her dig her own grave. I slipped a digital voice recorder into my breast pocket and hit record before I stepped out of the truck.
The diner was mostly empty at 3 PM. I spotted them in a back booth. My Aunt Martha looked nervous, stirring her coffee incessantly. My mother, however, looked remarkably put-together for someone who had just spent the weekend sleeping on a concrete slab. Her hair was brushed, her makeup applied, but the hardened, desperate look in her eyes betrayed her calm facade.
I slid into the booth across from them. I didn't order anything. "What do you have of Evelyn's?" I demanded.
Judith reached into her designer handbag—likely bought with my stolen credit card—and pulled out a small, velvet jewelry box. She slid it across the Formica table.
I opened it. Inside was a beautiful, antique diamond ring. It belonged to Evelyn’s late grandmother. Evelyn had been searching for it for months, utterly devastated that she had "lost" it during the chaotic first weeks after Jamie’s birth.
"You stole her grandmother's ring?" I hissed, the restraint it took not to flip the table requiring every ounce of my willpower.
"I was keeping it safe," Judith said smoothly, waving a dismissive hand. "She was so disorganized. I didn't want it getting lost."
"Why am I here, Judith?" I asked, snapping the box shut and pocketing it.
"I want to make a deal," she said, leaning forward, lowering her voice. "I know you spoke to Brenda. Marcus told me. You have me backed into a corner, Colin. But you are forgetting one very important thing."
"Oh? And what is that?"
"You are bankrupt," she smiled, a chilling, serpentine curve of her lips. "I took everything. Your credit score is in the low 400s. Your accounts are overdrawn. You have a mortgage payment due in ten days, and you don't have a dime to pay it. You are going to lose the house anyway."
She paused, letting the reality of my financial ruin hang in the air.
"But," she continued, "I have sixty thousand dollars hidden in a private lockbox. Cash. Untraceable by the courts. Drop the charges. Tell the police it was a misunderstanding with the deed. If you make this all go away... I’ll give you thirty thousand. Enough to pay off the immediate debt and save your house. If you refuse, I go to prison, and you, Evelyn, and my grandson end up homeless on the street."
She leaned back, crossing her arms, looking incredibly smug. She thought she had outsmarted me. She thought she had found the perfect leverage.
I reached into my pocket, but I didn't pull out the recorder. I pulled out my phone and dialed a number.
May you like
"Who are you calling?" Aunt Martha asked, panicking.
"Detective Miller?" I said into the phone, maintaining dead-eye contact with my mother as her smug smile vanished. "Yes, it's Colin Ashford. I'm at the diner on 4th street. My mother just confessed to hiding sixty thousand dollars in stolen funds in a private lockbox, and she just attempted to bribe a witness to drop felony charges. Yes, I have it all on a digital recorder. I'll wait right here for your patrol cars."
